Master Pigment Pro® Pencil - Matita eyeliner

The one good thing is that it doesn’t smudge at al

I was really excited to try the Makeup by Mario eye pencil after all the hype ✨ But honestly, I’m not too happy with the application — it doesn’t glide on as smoothly as I expected 😕 The one good thing is that it doesn’t smudge at all, which I love! 🖤

Sharpener included 😍

Omg . I was thinking on the ride home what kind of sharpener to use as all my lip liner sharpeners would make this product to sharp to be comfortable for use. I open the box after purchasing… and it comes w/ a sharpener!!! That made my day 🥰

Meh

The pigment was not what I was expecting, as it was a super light brown. It also flaked a bunch when I was using it which got all over my cheeks and was hard to smoke out. I like the brush at the end though!

No

Very nice and smooth I like the smidge brush however I hate the eyeliner!! It’s very messy and gets all over! For that, the 2 I bought are going in trash

Okay products

These eyeliners are pretty good but I just wish they smoked out easier! I hurt my eye trying to get it to smoke out! I swear nowadays there are no eyeshadows that smoke out easily!

Loveee this pencil! 🖤 It’s super pigmented, glides on effortlessly, and makes bold, defined eyes in seconds. Smooth application + long-lasting. Just note, because it’s designed to smudge, it can transfer a bit.

Love this!

This eyeliner is beautifully pigmented and long lasting . Glides on seamlessly and is easy to blend, but work quickly because it will set down.

Not worth the price

Disappointed, especially for the price tag. After sharpening it, when placing the product in my waterline, it was not super black like when I used it the first time. It was barely "grey" like some cheap drug store eyeliners. My friend had the same problem! Doubly disappointed when using it as an eyeliner on the lid at the immediate transfer: I have partially hooded lids so some liners make a "stamp" when I open my eye. Even when adding eyeshadow on top of the liner, it still transfers. I recommend getting LA Girl Glide Gel liner if you're looking for a super black.

A must have!

Love this eyeliner. Smoothe and easy application. Perfect for everyday use also.

Broken

Pencil got broken and core is dropping off it each time I open. Colour is good but quality of the pencil disappointed

I just got this makeup by Mario liner and it goes on super smooth..I like how it has a sharpener as well. The one thing I hate is if it smuges but I was super smooth on my eyelid.. Definitely will get this again!

I really wanted to love this but she needs some work when it comes to longevity. The pigment is there but in not even one to two hours the product began to wear off. At this price point as well as the reputation of this brand I am left disappointed for sure.